Skip to main content

Lunatic, Liar, or Lord

The readings for this homily: https://bible.usccb.org/bible/readings/012426.cfm

Father Jason Lewis, MIC confronts a question that has echoed since the time of Christ: Who is Jesus, really? As the Gospel recounts, some of Jesus’ own relatives believed He was “out of his mind,” while the scribes accused Him of acting by the power of evil. Yet Jesus’ works—healing the sick, casting out demons, forgiving sins—force a decision that cannot be avoided.

Father Jason draws on the classic trilemma, popularized by C.S. Lewis: Jesus can only be one of three things—lunatic, liar, or Lord. A mere “good moral teacher” is not an option. As Lewis argued, a man who claimed divine authority and spoke as Jesus did could not simply be misunderstood or exaggerated. Either His claims were false, making Him gravely deceptive or delusional, or they were true, demanding our faith and obedience. Scripture itself bears witness to this truth: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God… and the Word became flesh and dwelt among us” (Jn 1:1, 14; NABRE).

The Church has always proclaimed this same confession of faith. Saint Peter declared, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God” (Mt 16:16; NABRE), not by human reasoning alone, but by revelation from the Father. Father Jason reminds us that the fruit of Christ’s life and teachings confirms this identity. Lies do not produce saints. Deception does not transform the world through sacrificial love, truth, and mercy across centuries.

Because Jesus is Lord, He does more than teach—He gives Himself. In the Eucharist, entrusted to the Apostles and handed down through the priesthood, Christ remains truly present to nourish His people and draw them into divine life. This is the heart of the Gospel and the foundation of Christian faith.

Added to Favorites!
Added to Listen Later!

You might also like...

Fr. Allen Alexander explains one of the most commonly asked questions: What does it mean that Jesus descended into Hell? Was this the hell of the damned? Or a different place? The answer might surprise you.
Father Anthony reflects on how this passage reveals Christ’s mission and reminds us that every good work must begin with calling on the Holy Spirit. Join us as we explore how the Spirit empowers us to serve, uplift the vulnerable, and live out the Gospel in daily life.
Father Anthony reflects on the risen Christ who meets weary travelers along the road after the Resurrection, drawing near when hope feels thin and understanding incomplete. He explores how Jesus is first recognized not by dramatic signs, but by presence—walking, listening, sharing the journey—until he sits with them, shows them His hands, and even eats fish, showing a love that is real, embodied, and near. What appears ordinary slowly becomes holy as their eyes are opened to the truth that the stranger is the Lord.